This is a winner.
I’ve broken it out at a few events, and got instant responses – one person said “I’ve found my drink” after only a couple sips. If you are partial to browns and like your citrus, step on over to this. Even if you don’t, and one of my sisters-in-law does not like Bourbon at all, had one after tasting her husband’s.
1.5 oz Bourbon (Bulleit)
1 oz dry vermouth (Dolin)
.5 oz grenadine (homemade – that will be my next post)
.5 oz lemon juice
2 dashes orange bitters (Regan’s Orange Bitters No. 6)
Shake with ice, strain into chilled cocktail glass or rocks glass, garnish with lemon peel.
It’s got the core of a whiskey sour, but added herbal elements from the vermouth and more fruit sweetness from the grenadine.
This recipe is closest to Imbibe‘s, but I dropped down the grenadine and lemon juice and switched from rye to bourbon. Gary Regan published this calling for 2 oz of bourbon, but dropped the lemon juice to 1/2 oz and grenadine to 1/4 oz and has orange bitters, but I thought that was a tad too bitter and too boozy. Erik Ellestad followed Harry Craddock’s recipe strictly – that equalizes the whisky (not the lack of an ‘e’ – Canadian Whisky) and vermouth and keeps bitters in.
So I like it at this level, but if you want it a bit stronger, take the Bourbon up to 2 ounces and the lemon juice and grenadine up to 3/4 of an ounce for each.
The Trophy Wife likes to corrupt everything with a sweet Maraschino Cherry, so I’m going to have to order the Amarena Fabbri again, but I’m going to work on making our own cherries, more on the next post.