Mmmm. Love the Manhattan Cocktail.
Chance came on Thanksgiving Day, 2009, to try a couple variations on the basic bourbon manhattan. I had two companions in the tasting – my brother in law Rob, and his friend Dean. Forgive me if I cannot recapture in words all the subtle nuances of all the flavors, but we did sample six different recipes.
The classic recipe:
2 oz bourbon or blended whiskey (that night, all Maker’s Mark)
1 oz sweet vermouth (Martini & Rossi)
2 dashes Angostura bitters
1 maraschino cherry for garnish
A set of simple variations:
- The classic manhattan
- The perfect manhattan (substitute 1/2 oz of the sweet vermouth with 1/2 oz dry vermouth (Noilly Prat here)
- The classic but with 1 dash Angostura bitter and 1 dash of Peychaud’s bitters
Between these three, it was a very close race. I had a slight preference for the classic recipe’s balance with this bourbon, with the perfect manhattan coming a very close second. The Peychaud’s added a bit of an unfamiliar twist – one most welcome in a Sazerac, but not quite right with the manhattan.
We each tasted each of the three options, then each chose one to drink.
Three slightly more creative recipes:
- The classic, but replace all the bitters with Blood Orange Bitters from Stirrings.
- A recipe described in Gary Regan’s The Joy of Mixology – “Kentucky’s Best”. See below.
- One that I dreamed up, splitting the vermouth to 1/2 oz sweet vermouth and 1/2 oz Campari
These three all drifted much farther afield from what my mouth was prepared for. Not quite bad drinks, but not “to style”.
The one that, to me, bordered on unpleasant, was the 3rd. 1/2 oz of Campari was too much in there. I loves me the Negroni (equal parts gin, sweet vermouth, and Campari – we’ll talk about this drink in another post), but it destroyed the balance here. I’ll try again using a dash or two of Campari to replace the bitters at some other date.
The second was also a little unusual. In fairness, I did use a “vintage” port instead of a ruby, and Maker’s Mark instead of Knob Creek. Both Maker’s and Knob are on the sweeter side for bourbons, so kinda comparable. There was just too much going on in this drink.
Finally, the orange bitters didn’t quite taste right in this. I’ll mix it up again some time, but Round 1 recipes all were preferable to the Round 2 drinks.
The variables that we left for future testings:
- Bourbons – Knob Creek, Maker’s Mark, Heaven Hill, Woodford Reserve, Wild Turkey, and so many others…
- Blended Whiskies/Whiskeys – Canadian or not, with varying amounts of rye
- Sweet Vermouth balances – reducing by 1/4 or 1/2 an ounce when mixing with sweeter Bourbons or increasing
So, as you may have guessed by the “Part 1” in the header, this will be an recurring project, with time to “clear the palate” (i.e. recover from the hangover) in between.
Finally, that recipe for “Kentucky’s Best” Manhattan recipe – it’s available through Google books, but here it is directly:
2 ounces Knob Creek bourbon
1/4 oz maraschino cherry juice
3 dashes ruby port
3 dashes Martini & Rossi sweet vermouth
2 dashes creme de cassis
1 dash Angostura bitters
1 maraschino cherry, for garnish
Stir and strain into a chilled cocktail glass. Add the garnish.